It's difficult to get too far into the topic of international rankings without getting into modern politics but it's safe to say that this particular person is looking to advance a particular (fairly misleading) message. This is to say, it can be true if we look at a particular set of data but it's functionally meaningless. I've written before about the history of the United States Education Department and the tl;dr is that the creation of the department was more an organizational shift than a policy change to anything that happened in American schools. From an older response : The creation of the Education Department (technically USED, technically USDOE is the United States Department of Energy) was mostly an organizational change related to existing structures. Henry Barnard, recognized as one of the founders of the common school movement, and the National Teachers Association (later the National Educational Association) advocated for a federal bureau following the Civil War. In effect, they saw the bureau's role as a support mechanism for Western and Southern states and territories looking to establish schools and education systems, similar to how the Department of Agriculture was set up to support farmers. The Bureau served primarily as an information warehouse and data collection system. Staff traveled around the country and wrote reports detailing budgets, infrastructure, salaries, textbooks, demographics, and more. There were attempts to abolish the Bureau but chiefs and various Congressmen fought for its sustained existence for a variety of reasons, including the argument that it benefitted Congress to have a sense of the national landscape of education, and the only people who could do that was the federal government. The Bureau picked up additional responsibilities as time passed, including the management of schools in the Alaska Territory, the Indian Boarding Schools, Department of Defense schools, and some international educational oversight. In 1952, the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare (HEW) was created, including the United States Office of Education. The office was given additional responsibilities, including the management of federal funds for districts including for those that included military bases within their attendance zones. By this point, every state in the country had its own state education system, including, in most cases, preliminary requirements around curriculum frameworks (known in today's parlance as "standards.") Which is to say, the foundations for what American education looked like was fairly well-established through policy at state level and cultural transmission by the 1950s. The launch of Sputnik in 1957 changed dynamics in American schools related to math and Science in (a little more on that here ) and the USOE helped provide grants to states for math and science teachers' professional development and new textbooks. However, the USOE wasn't the only place in the federal government dealing with education. There was an office in the Department of Defense that dealt with schools on military bases, the Department of the Interior, National Science Foundation, etc. The Department of Educational Reorganization Act passed by Congress and signed by President Carter in 1979 sought to streamline, organize, and increase the role of the federal government in education. This Act also created a new cabinet position, The Secretary of Education. Almost immediately, there was pushback from the Republican Congress. Students didn't really see an impact of the Office on their daily lives. The most common way, though, a young person would cross paths with the office was if something was going wrong. A combination of the passage of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act in 1965, the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Education Amendments of 1972, Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, the Age Discrimination Act of 1975, and the Educational for All Handicapped Children in 1975 led to a need for an Office of Civil Rights inside the ED. The office, also created in 1979, positioned the federal government as an ally to students. That is, students and their families who felt a district was infringing on their Civil Rights - and the state wasn't responding or disagreed - could turn to the newly formed USED for legal support.

Answer from EdHistory101 on reddit.com
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/askhistorians › is it true that the u.s. education system was #1 in the world until the inception of the department of education in 1979?
r/AskHistorians on Reddit: Is it true that the U.S. education system ...

It's difficult to get too far into the topic of international rankings without getting into modern politics but it's safe to say that this particular person is looking to advance a particular (fairly misleading) message. This is to say, it can be true if we look at a particular set of data but it's functionally meaningless.

I've written before about the history of the United States Education Department and the tl;dr is that the creation of the department was more an organizational shift than a policy change to anything that happened in American schools. From an older response:

The creation of the Education Department (technically USED, technically USDOE is the United States Department of Energy) was mostly an organizational change related to existing structures. Henry Barnard, recognized as one of the founders of the common school movement, and the National Teachers Association (later the National Educational Association) advocated for a federal bureau following the Civil War. In effect, they saw the bureau's role as a support mechanism for Western and Southern states and territories looking to establish schools and education systems, similar to how the Department of Agriculture was set up to support farmers. The Bureau served primarily as an information warehouse and data collection system. Staff traveled around the country and wrote reports detailing budgets, infrastructure, salaries, textbooks, demographics, and more.

There were attempts to abolish the Bureau but chiefs and various Congressmen fought for its sustained existence for a variety of reasons, including the argument that it benefitted Congress to have a sense of the national landscape of education, and the only people who could do that was the federal government. The Bureau picked up additional responsibilities as time passed, including the management of schools in the Alaska Territory, the Indian Boarding Schools, Department of Defense schools, and some international educational oversight.

In 1952, the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare (HEW) was created, including the United States Office of Education. The office was given additional responsibilities, including the management of federal funds for districts including for those that included military bases within their attendance zones. By this point, every state in the country had its own state education system, including, in most cases, preliminary requirements around curriculum frameworks (known in today's parlance as "standards.") Which is to say, the foundations for what American education looked like was fairly well-established through policy at state level and cultural transmission by the 1950s.

The launch of Sputnik in 1957 changed dynamics in American schools related to math and Science in (a little more on that here) and the USOE helped provide grants to states for math and science teachers' professional development and new textbooks. However, the USOE wasn't the only place in the federal government dealing with education. There was an office in the Department of Defense that dealt with schools on military bases, the Department of the Interior, National Science Foundation, etc. The Department of Educational Reorganization Act passed by Congress and signed by President Carter in 1979 sought to streamline, organize, and increase the role of the federal government in education. This Act also created a new cabinet position, The Secretary of Education. Almost immediately, there was pushback from the Republican Congress.

Students didn't really see an impact of the Office on their daily lives. The most common way, though, a young person would cross paths with the office was if something was going wrong. A combination of the passage of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act in 1965, the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Education Amendments of 1972, Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, the Age Discrimination Act of 1975, and the Educational for All Handicapped Children in 1975 led to a need for an Office of Civil Rights inside the ED. The office, also created in 1979, positioned the federal government as an ally to students. That is, students and their families who felt a district was infringing on their Civil Rights - and the state wasn't responding or disagreed - could turn to the newly formed USED for legal support.

🌐
Ed
nces.ed.gov › pubs93 › 93442.pdf pdf
120 Years of American Education: A Statistical Portrait
The National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) collects, analyzes and makes available data related to education in the U.S. and other nations.
Discussions

IsItBullshit: U.S. now spends double on education since 1960s while math/reading scores remain virtually the same?

🌐 r/IsItBullshit
165
December 10, 2021
459 votes, 165 comments. Saw this in a presentation: the U.S. has spent 192% more on education from 1960 to the 2010s, while math & reading scores… More on reddit.com

Is it true that the U.S. education system was #1 in the world until the inception of the Department of Education in 1979?

🌐 r/AskHistorians
11
October 20, 2020

Welcome to r/AskHistorians. Please Read Our Rules before you comment in this community. Understand that rule breaking comments get removed.

Please consider Clicking Here for RemindMeBot as it takes time for an answer to be written.

We thank you for your interest in this question, and your patience in waiting for an in-depth and comprehensive answer to show up. In addition to RemindMeBot, consider using our Browser Extension, or getting the Weekly Roundup. In the meantime our Twitter, Facebook, and Sunday Digest feature excellent content that has already been written!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

More on reddit.com
🌐
Snopes
snopes.com › homepage › fact check
US Has Dropped from 1st to 24th Worldwide in Education Since 1979?
4 weeks ago - There was no evidence to support the claim that since Carter founded the Department of Education in 1979, the U.S. has dropped from first to 24th worldwide in education. Rather, one report found that U.S. students' scores were "lagging behind" students from other developed countries from the 1960s through 1988, and another analysis found that, on average, student achievement in the U.S. had increased between 1971 and 2017. As of this writing, rankings ...
🌐
USA Today
usatoday.com › story › news › factcheck › 2024 › 11 › 22 › us-education-rank-1979-fact-check › 76451360007
No, US student ranks didn't plummet after Department of Education ...
3 weeks ago - U.S. News & World Report ranked ... public education system, whether respondents would consider attending university there and if that country has a reputation for top-quality universities.” The news outlet has only ranked countries in that way for nine years. There is no evidence of any widespread decline in student achievement in the U.S. since 1979, Carnoy said. U.S. math scores have been below many other countries for decades. In the mid-1960s, ...
🌐
Statista
statista.com › statistics › 184260 › educational-attainment-in-the-us
Educational attainment in the U.S. 1960-2022 | Statista
August 22, 2024 - Educational attainment in the U.S. 1960-2022 · Educational attainment in the U.S. 2022 · Forbes ranking of the best U.S.

It's difficult to get too far into the topic of international rankings without getting into modern politics but it's safe to say that this particular person is looking to advance a particular (fairly misleading) message. This is to say, it can be true if we look at a particular set of data but it's functionally meaningless. I've written before about the history of the United States Education Department and the tl;dr is that the creation of the department was more an organizational shift than a policy change to anything that happened in American schools. From an older response : The creation of the Education Department (technically USED, technically USDOE is the United States Department of Energy) was mostly an organizational change related to existing structures. Henry Barnard, recognized as one of the founders of the common school movement, and the National Teachers Association (later the National Educational Association) advocated for a federal bureau following the Civil War. In effect, they saw the bureau's role as a support mechanism for Western and Southern states and territories looking to establish schools and education systems, similar to how the Department of Agriculture was set up to support farmers. The Bureau served primarily as an information warehouse and data collection system. Staff traveled around the country and wrote reports detailing budgets, infrastructure, salaries, textbooks, demographics, and more. There were attempts to abolish the Bureau but chiefs and various Congressmen fought for its sustained existence for a variety of reasons, including the argument that it benefitted Congress to have a sense of the national landscape of education, and the only people who could do that was the federal government. The Bureau picked up additional responsibilities as time passed, including the management of schools in the Alaska Territory, the Indian Boarding Schools, Department of Defense schools, and some international educational oversight. In 1952, the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare (HEW) was created, including the United States Office of Education. The office was given additional responsibilities, including the management of federal funds for districts including for those that included military bases within their attendance zones. By this point, every state in the country had its own state education system, including, in most cases, preliminary requirements around curriculum frameworks (known in today's parlance as "standards.") Which is to say, the foundations for what American education looked like was fairly well-established through policy at state level and cultural transmission by the 1950s. The launch of Sputnik in 1957 changed dynamics in American schools related to math and Science in (a little more on that here ) and the USOE helped provide grants to states for math and science teachers' professional development and new textbooks. However, the USOE wasn't the only place in the federal government dealing with education. There was an office in the Department of Defense that dealt with schools on military bases, the Department of the Interior, National Science Foundation, etc. The Department of Educational Reorganization Act passed by Congress and signed by President Carter in 1979 sought to streamline, organize, and increase the role of the federal government in education. This Act also created a new cabinet position, The Secretary of Education. Almost immediately, there was pushback from the Republican Congress. Students didn't really see an impact of the Office on their daily lives. The most common way, though, a young person would cross paths with the office was if something was going wrong. A combination of the passage of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act in 1965, the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Education Amendments of 1972, Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, the Age Discrimination Act of 1975, and the Educational for All Handicapped Children in 1975 led to a need for an Office of Civil Rights inside the ED. The office, also created in 1979, positioned the federal government as an ally to students. That is, students and their families who felt a district was infringing on their Civil Rights - and the state wasn't responding or disagreed - could turn to the newly formed USED for legal support.

Answer from EdHistory101 on reddit.com
🌐
The Balance
thebalancemoney.com › the-u-s-is-losing-its-competitive-advantage-3306225
U.S. Education Rankings Are Falling Behind the Rest of the World
July 11, 2024 - U.S. students' math scores have remained steady since 2003. Their science scores have been about the same since 2006. The IMD World Competitiveness Center reports that the U.S. ranked 12th in its 2024 Competitiveness Report after ranking first in 2018.
🌐
Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org › wiki › Education_in_the_United_States
Education in the United States - Wikipedia
July 29, 2020 - However, the United States is ranked 37th in the world in education spending as a percentage of gross domestic product. Government figures exist for education spending in the United States per student, and by state. They show a very wide range of expenditures and a steady increase in per-pupil ...
Find elsewhere
🌐
Cft
cft.org › article › how-american-education-has-changed-leave-it-beaver
How American education has changed since "Leave it to Beaver" - ...
September 16, 2019 - More important than the SAT is the National Assessment of Educational Progress, often called “the nation’s report card.” Since its introduction in 1969, NAEP scores have been on a slow but steady upward trajectory. The high school curriculum is more rigorous today than it was in 1960, as are college entrance requirements. I needed only two years of high school math to get into college, but both my daughters had to have at least three. When I attended the Burbank public schools, California ranked ...
🌐
Ed
nces.ed.gov › fastfacts › display.asp
Fast Facts: Long-term trends in reading and mathematics achievement ...
June 8, 2023 - Search Publications and Products Annual Reports Restricted-use Data Licenses Recent Publications By Subject Index A-Z By Survey & Program Areas Data Products Last 6 Months ... Since the 1970s, the long-term trend National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) has reported periodic data ...
🌐
Blogs
blog.aarp.org › bulletin-today › u-s-global-education-rankings-slipping-boomers-once-held-strong-lead
U.S. Global Education Rankings Slipping, Boomers Once Held Strong Lead
June 19, 2013 - But Americans ages 25 to 34 only rank 10th in the world in high school diplomas, and they've dropped to 13th in attaining post-secondary degrees. It's not that 25-to-34-year-olds are less educated than boomers: 88 percent of them earned high school diplomas, compared with 90 percent of boomers, ...
🌐
HistoryNet
historynet.com › home › was the usa ever no. 1 in education?
Was the USA ever No. 1 in education?
September 2, 2022 - Having matured on the battlefield, ... middle class in the 1950s and 1960s. In 2009, the United States was ranked 18th out of 36 industrialized nations. Over that time, complacency and inefficiency, reflective of lower priorities in education, and inconsistencies among the various ...
🌐
Education Next
educationnext.org › home › ticket to nowhere
Ticket to Nowhere - Education Next
January 16, 2024 - These highfliers had attended school ... to put together an education system that could serve more than an elite cadre. Americans who went to school during the 1960s ranked a respectable 3rd; those schooled in the 1970s ranked 5th....
🌐
Quora
quora.com › In-the-60s-and-70s-American-schools-were-among-the-best-in-the-world-What-happened
In the ‘60s and ‘70s, American schools were among the best ...
Answer (1 of 10): What happened? Social engineering and experimentation, using children as lab rats. Over a half a century ago, school desegregation, accomplished by bussing nearly tore the country apart. Judicially mandated reassignment of students to achieve “racial balance” proved to ...
🌐
Quora
quora.com › Is-it-true-that-a-ranking-for-education-in-the-US-has-remained-stagnant-for-two-decades
Is it true that a ranking for education in the US has remained ...
Answer: Everything depends on who you ask and how they have assembled their data, if indeed they have any data at all! What I think I’m hearing through all the static is that people want more from public education. I’m ok with that :-) “Just how you gonna pay for that mister?” It’s ...
🌐
Our World in Data
ourworldindata.org › global-education
Global Education - Our World in Data
January 1, 2013 - See all our data, visualizations, and writing on global education.
🌐
Usnews
usnews.com › home › best states
Rankings: Education - States With the Best Education
August 28, 2023 - How well is your state educating students? US News ranks states on education, including pre-K-12 and college, based on graduation rates, test scores and more.
🌐
Pew Research Center
pewresearch.org › home › research topics › other topics › education › k-12
U.S. students’ academic achievement still lags that of their ...
April 14, 2024 - American students continue to rank around the middle of the pack, and behind many other advanced industrial nations, in international assessments of math, science and reading.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/isitbullshit › isitbullshit: u.s. now spends double on education since 1960s while math/reading scores remain virtually the same?
r/IsItBullshit on Reddit: IsItBullshit: U.S. now spends double ...
December 10, 2021 - 459 votes, 165 comments. Saw this in a presentation: the U.S. has spent 192% more on education from 1960 to the 2010s, while math & reading scores…