What’s the difference between Economics and Political Economy?
(Everyone) Is economics a political matter, in your opinion?
What exactly is a Political Economy?
Political Economy: is it always necessary to understand the economy in order to do a political analysis related to the effects and phenomena within an economy? And who does actually understand the economy anyway?
The former is more commonly used while the latter often refers to Marx and the classical school. How are these two trades related and what sets them apart?
Not too much else to say about the question, but I will provide my opinion.
First I will define economics as the means by which resources are made and allocated. I feel that this is a fair and neutral definition that encompasses the spectrum of systems we have seen, both presently and historically. If you have problem with the definition, please make note in the comment.
Second, I will define politics. I believe there to be certain conditions that must exist before politics is an existential phenomenon. One, there must be a commonly recognized organization(commonly a government) made up of people you don’t know. Two, there must be people who you may or may not know who have the power to make decisions under the pretense that they are enforceable.
Thus, I define politics as the making of decisions on behalf of an organization, under the pretense that they are enforceable. Again, if you have problem with the definition, let me know.
TLDR; economics is the means by which resources are made/allocated. Politics is the making of decisions that are understood to be enforceable.
So is economics a political matter? To ask this question is to ask whether the people making/allocating the resources 1. Make decisions that are enforceable(by persuasion, coercion, force, or other means), 2. Make decisions based on the enforceability of other peoples decisions(commonly government, but maybe other organizations).
If the people making/allocating the resources make decisions based on their own singular intent, I would say no, economics is not political. But if their actions are based on the enforceability of someone else’s decisions, I would say yes, economics is thoroughly a political matter. Under this definition, many things not conventionally understood as political would be considered political. I’m okay with that.
To answer my own question, yes, I believe that economics in any present system is absolutely a political matter.