Isaiah 53 is part of the Servant Song cycle in Deutero-Isaiah (ch. 40-55). Deutero-Isaiah was written in the late exilic and early post-exilic period. The first portion was probably written c. 540 BC, i.e. shortly before Cyrus conquered Babylon (as the text draws on the Cyrus Proclamation yet does not reflect what happened when Babylon fell). The Servant Songs may have been written a decade or two later. Trito-Isaiah (ch. 56-66) dates even later, to the fifth century BC. The servant is usually understood as representing Israel, although the fourth song seem to pertain either to an individualized personification of Israel or an actual individual (speculative suggestions have included Zerubabbel, Haggai, Zechariah, or someone unknown to history). Answer from zanillamilla on reddit.com
Reddit
reddit.com › r/academicbiblical › when was the ''book of isaiah'' written? has the translation been altered to fit the ''messianic prophecy'' agenda?
r/AcademicBiblical on Reddit: When was the ''Book of Isaiah'' written? Has the translation been altered to fit the ''Messianic Prophecy'' agenda?
June 3, 2019 -
I have been reading about Isaiah 53 and how the original scroll didn't say ''pierced'' but rather another thing. Apart from that, it doesn't seem to be talking about the Messiah in the least but rather about Israel as a nation (through the metaphor and duality of Israel a.k.a. Jacob). I also wonder: was this book written after the Babylonian Exile? If it was, I'm assuming it was written to give the Jewish people hope for a better tomorrow and as an explanation of why ''God woul allow such things to happen''. What do you say?
Top answer 1 of 2
7
Isaiah 53 is part of the Servant Song cycle in Deutero-Isaiah (ch. 40-55). Deutero-Isaiah was written in the late exilic and early post-exilic period. The first portion was probably written c. 540 BC, i.e. shortly before Cyrus conquered Babylon (as the text draws on the Cyrus Proclamation yet does not reflect what happened when Babylon fell). The Servant Songs may have been written a decade or two later. Trito-Isaiah (ch. 56-66) dates even later, to the fifth century BC. The servant is usually understood as representing Israel, although the fourth song seem to pertain either to an individualized personification of Israel or an actual individual (speculative suggestions have included Zerubabbel, Haggai, Zechariah, or someone unknown to history).
2 of 2
1
When it comes to Isa 53:5 some translations use "wounded" (i.e. KJV and CEV) and others (ESV/NIV/NAS) go with "pierced". And, no, the translation wasn't changed to fit an agenda. Whether or not Isaiah 53 refers to the Messiah or the nation of Israel is certainly up for dispute. Historically the church has contended it is about Jesus and sees clear parallels between it and Jesus' death. Scholars, generally say it is about Israel. Personally, I don't think it has to be approached as an "either/or", and can be about both.
Do you believe all of the Book of Isaiah was written by the prophet Isaiah in the 8th century BC? Jun 30, 2025
r/AskAChristian last yr.
Bart Ehrman Blog
ehrmanblog.org › home › does isaiah 53 predict jesus’ suffering and death or has isaiah 53 been debunked?
Does Isaiah 53 Predict Jesus' Suffering and Death or Has Isaiah 53 Been Debunked? - The Bart Ehrman Blog
September 10, 2025 - Nope, not true at all. Next time ask them for the references. If they give them to you, look them up. And pay close attention to when the sources were written! There is no reference to Isaiah 53 as messianic prior to Christianity.
prophecy - Does the past tense in the suffering servant song (Isaiah 53) refer to Jesus? - Biblical Hermeneutics Stack Exchange
Isaiah 53:10 tells us of this one that was put to death (vs9} will see his seed, which is in future tense form (naphsho yireh zerah) It appears that many times His Messianic prophecies are written in past tense, speaking to those in the future, as in today, who will look at it as something ... More on hermeneutics.stackexchange.com
Is Isaiah 53 really about Jesus?
Isaiah 53 in particular cannot be about Israel. This suffering servant is righteous and guiltless, how can this be about Israel when the same Isaiah says Israel was exiled by sin (42:24-25), is blind and deaf (43:8), fails to call on the Lord (43:22-28), God is angry with them (47:6), is guilty and has exile foretold (48:1-6), and was sent away (50:1). The overwhelming consensus of the early rabbis was that Isaiah 53 was about an individual, with some interpreting it to be messiah. The modern Jewish reading is a reactionary response to the true Christian reading. More on reddit.com
40
6
April 21, 2025Isaiah 53 seems to be irrefutable proof of Christianity
The Jewish interpretation is that Isaiah 53 is speaking about Israel from the perspective of the Gentiles who persecuted it. It's not a messianic text. Even from a Christian perspective, it does not speak of Jesus as Messiah, but of Jesus as the recapitulation of Israel, going into exile with His people on the cross and returning in glory through the resurrection (not that this interpretation can be reconciled with the Jewish one anyway, as Isaiah 53 isn't understood to be said from the perspective of Jesus's enemies but rather from all mankind's, and Him bearing our suffering isn't understood to mean we persecuted Him but rather that He suffered to deliver us). So, Isaiah 53 is really not a bulletproof demonstration that Christianity is true. Jews read this text and don't see anything about the Messiah. More on reddit.com
151
25
October 31, 2024Isaiah 53 and Psalm 22
If you read all of Psalm 22, it's not actually a prophecy about the messiah or about crucifixion, but it's a lament poem about someone who is afflicted by trouble and then vindicated by God. Verse 16 is often mistranslated with the word "pierce" to make it fit a christological context better. (The exact meaning of verse 16 is not known, which is a long-standing problem in biblical studies.) However, the author of Mark made clever use of the images and symbolism in Psalm 22 in his passion story, and of course Jesus is shown to quote a line from it in Aramaic on the cross. The date of authorship of the Psalm is not known. The last portion is generally thought to have been composed later. The oldest surviving manuscript is from the Dead Sea Scrolls. I can't find an exact date, but maybe around 100 BCE. John Day summarizes it in his commentary on Psalms: Psalm 22, an individual lament, is echoed primarily in the gospel passion narratives. Jesus' cry from the cross, Eloi, Eloi, lama sabachthani, 'My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?', cites Ps. 22.1 in Aramaic: it may well be that these words, which have often been found puzzling,have the wider context of the psalm in mind, which ends on a note of vindication and of the universal coming of the kingdom of God (Ps. 22,22-31). Other echoes of this psalm are the deriding of Jesus and the wagging of heads at him (Mk 15.29; Mt. 27.39; Lk. 23.35; cf. Ps. 22.7), the division of Jesus' garments and casting lots for them (Mk 15.24; Mt. 27.35; Lk. 23.34; Jn 19.24; cf. Ps. 22.18) and the demand that God deliver him (Mt. 27.43; cf. Ps. 22.8). One can obviously debate how far these allusions reflect historical episodes and how far they simply represent the reading of these psalm passages into the passion narrative. More on reddit.com
23
11
May 31, 2023Is Isaiah 53 About Jesus?
09:52
Isaiah 53 - Bible Study, Explanation, and Application - YouTube
30:33
Mind-blowing Proof Isaiah 53 points to Jesus?! 🤯🤯 | Case ...
47:13
Isaiah 53: Prophecy Explained - YouTube
43:13
Isaiah 53 the FORBIDDEN chapter? Dr James Tour talks Science, ...
26:30
The Mysterious Prophecy of Isaiah 53 - YouTube
Isaiah 53
isaiah53.com › home › frequently asked questions
Frequently Asked Questions - Isaiah 53
April 22, 2019 - One of the most important archeological ... and scribal dating studies, place the scroll at 150-100 B.C. This is incontrovertible evidence that Isaiah 53 was written before the time of Jesus....
Top answer 1 of 13
12
Isaiah did not write in the past tense. Biblical Hebrew does not employ tenses in the same way as English or Greek do. Isaiah wrote this chapter in perfect aspect ie he saw the actions of the verbs as whole/ complete without respect to their timing1
Prophecy is often presented in the perfect aspect as it is direct revelation from God the actions are not been viewed in relation to time but certainty of accomplishment2.
1 based on by Heiser, M. S., & Setterholm, V. M. (2013; 2013). In Glossary of Morpho-Syntactic Database Terminology. Lexham Press.
2 see here for more information on the prophetic perfect
2 of 13
10
Rabbi David Kimchi (דוד קמחי), also known as RaDaK (רד"ק), who lived from 1160–1235 A.D., wrote this in his Sefer Mikhlol concerning the usage of the past tense in prophecies (which naturally concern future events):1
ותדע כי מנהג העוברי׳ בלשון הקדש להשתמש בו עבד במקום עתיד שהן אותיות א״יתן וזה בנבואות ברוב כי הדבר ברור כמו אם עבר כי כבר נגזר׳
And you should know that it is a typical behavior of the past tense verbs in the holy language to use a past tense verb in place of a future tense verb (which are [indicated by] the letters איתן), and this is mostly in prophecies because the matter is clear as if it passed, because it has already been decreed.
In regards to the servant passages of Isaiah, many do indeed refer to the nation of Israel, but at least one of them, Isaiah 49:1–9, cannot. In Isa. 49:3, the servant is certainly named “Israel,” yet this same servant is supposed to “bring back Jacob to” Yahveh,2 “to raise up the tribes of Jacob, and to restore the preserved of Israel.”3 If the servant named Israel is supposed to restore the preserved of Israel, then the scripture must be referring to two entities named Israel. The nation of Israel cannot bring itself back; the nation of Israel cannot raise itself; the nation of Israel cannot restore itself. Those labors and works are specifically assigned to the Messiah.4 It is the Messiah who is named Israel in Isa. 49:3, named after his ancestor Israel, just as he is elsewhere named after his ancestor David.5 The servant named Israel in Isa. 49:3 is thus the Messiah, while the Israel he is supposed to restore is the nation itself.
| Footnotes |
|---|
| 1 Folio 12b—יב 2 Isa. 49:5 3 Isa. 49:6 4 Isa. 11:11–12 5 cf. Jer. 30:9; Eze. 34:23, 37:24 |
| References |
|---|
| Kimchi, David (דוד קמחי). Sefer Mikhlol (ספר מכלול). Venice: Bomberg, 1545. |
Isaiah 53 is part of the Servant Song cycle in Deutero-Isaiah (ch. 40-55). Deutero-Isaiah was written in the late exilic and early post-exilic period. The first portion was probably written c. 540 BC, i.e. shortly before Cyrus conquered Babylon (as the text draws on the Cyrus Proclamation yet does not reflect what happened when Babylon fell). The Servant Songs may have been written a decade or two later. Trito-Isaiah (ch. 56-66) dates even later, to the fifth century BC. The servant is usually understood as representing Israel, although the fourth song seem to pertain either to an individualized personification of Israel or an actual individual (speculative suggestions have included Zerubabbel, Haggai, Zechariah, or someone unknown to history). Answer from zanillamilla on reddit.com
Creation
creation.com › en › articles › isaiah-author-date
Who wrote Isaiah? · Creation.com
September 30, 2011 - Then in v. 41 John affirms concerning these two verses, one from Isaiah “I” and the other from Isaiah “II”: “These things Isaiah said when he saw His glory and spoke of Him.” This surely implies that the inspired apostle believed that both Isaiah 6 and Isaiah 53 were written by the ...
Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org › wiki › Isaiah_53
Isaiah 53 - Wikipedia
June 16, 2026 - Isaiah 52:13–53:12 makes up the fourth of the "Servant Songs" of the Book of Isaiah, describing a "servant" of God who is abused and looked down upon but eventually vindicated. The original text was written in Biblical Hebrew. This chapter is divided into 12 verses, although the pericope ...
Facebook
facebook.com › craiggroeschel › photos › written-approximately-700-years-before-his-birth-isaiah-prophesied-what-the-suff › 2729926290399271
Written approximately 700 years before his birth, Isaiah ...
We cannot provide a description for this page right now
Jews for Judaism
jewsforjudaism.org › knowledge › articles › isaiah-53-explained
Jews for Judaism | Isaiah 53 Explained
September 16, 2013 - First, one must read the entire book of Isaiah in context and from an accurate Jewish translation (such as an Artscroll/ Mesorah Publication Bible). It was written by Isaiah who was a prophet from 619-533 B.C.E. In the original text there were ...
Quora
quora.com › Who-wrote-Isaiah-chapter-53-1
Who wrote Isaiah chapter 53? - Quora
Answer (1 of 8): I could take the easy way out and say that Isaiah chapter 53 was written by Isaiah, son of Amoz, just like the rest of the book—but I would be wrong. Most biblical scholars say Isaiah chapters 40–55 were actually written during the Babylonian Exile, by an anonymous writer ...
Rtbc
rtbc.faith › blog › the-wonderful-prophecy-of-isaiah-52-53
RTBC - The Wonderful Prophecy of Isaiah 52-53
March 7, 2023 - It gives us such a detailed picture of the way God has ordained for our rescue—it’s a picture of Christ’s death and resurrection in the middle of the Hebrew Scriptures written centuries before the things described. Only the omnipotent and omniscient God of the Bible could show this, and He does so through the prophet Isaiah.
The Master's University
masters.edu › home › isaiah’s message of judgment and grace
Isaiah’s Message of Judgment and Grace - The Master's University
June 4, 2024 - Isaiah is divided into two sections, chapters 1 through 39 and chapters 40 through 66. It is a long, very detailed, and magnificent Old Testament book. It was written about 680 B.C., nearly 700 years before Christ.
GotQuestions
gotquestions.org › Book-of-Isaiah.html
Summary of the Book of Isaiah - Bible Survey | GotQuestions.org
April 18, 2005 - You said in your heart, "I will ascend to heaven; I will raise my throne above the stars of God; I will sit enthroned on the mount of assembly, on the utmost heights of the sacred mountain.” Isaiah 53:5-6, “But he was pierced for our ...
X
x.com › HangtimeYT › status › 1711392613276770692
Michael Turk on X: "Isaiah 53 - In the Old Testament written ~700 years B.C, this is one of countless prophecies concerning Jesus. It describes in detail His death on the cross and payment for our sin. The Bible is a miraculous book! Your faith will be strengthened the more you realize that. https://t.co/IGi6iBVDu9" / X
Isaiah 53 - In the Old Testament written ~700 years B.C, this is one of countless prophecies concerning Jesus. It describes in detail His death on the cross and payment for our sin. The Bible is a miraculous book!
Medium
medium.com › koinonia › is-the-servant-in-isaiah-53-the-messiah-acb83c83ed38
Is the Servant in Isaiah 53 the Messiah? | by Nick Meader | Koinonia | Medium
May 24, 2021 - It is also clear why Christians from the start have considered this passage was about Jesus the Messiah. The overlap between Isaiah 53 (written 400–600 BCE) and the life of Jesus is striking:
Foi
radio.foi.org › home › the friends of israel today › september 17, 2022 | isaiah 53: humiliation to exaltation (rebroadcast)
September 17, 2022 | Isaiah 53: Humiliation to Exaltation (REBROADCAST) - The Friends of Israel Today Radio
September 23, 2022 - Before Jesus came to Earth, believers in the Old Testament time were somewhat blind to His depth, meaning, power, and significance. They only had bits of information from God’s prophetic Word to explain all that Jesus would encompass. This week, we’re going to look at how Isaiah 53, written 700 ...
Facebook
facebook.com › LifeInMessiah › posts › this-passage-from-isaiah-53-was-prophetically-written-700-years-before-the-birth › 1221572100005053
This passage from Isaiah 53 was prophetically written
We cannot provide a description for this page right now
Facebook
facebook.com › groups › therealmenofgod › posts › 2011234462655215
The book of Isaiah was written 700 years before Jesus! All ...
We cannot provide a description for this page right now
Facebook
facebook.com › groups › AMillionBaptists › posts › 4036891959700751
Isaiah 53 was written 700 years before Jesus walked ...
We cannot provide a description for this page right now
Jews for Jesus
jewsforjesus.org › home › evidence for jesus › is the meaning of isaiah 53 a description of jesus as suffering servant?
Is the Meaning of Isaiah 53 a Description of Jesus as Suffering Servant? - Jews for Jesus
March 12, 2026 - Behold my servant Messiah shall prosper; he shall be high, and increase, and be exceeding strong: as the house of Israel looked to him through many days, because their countenance was darkened among the peoples, and their complexion beyond the sons of men (Targum Jonathan on Isaiah 53, ad locum).2 · We find the same interpretation in the Babylonian Talmud: What is his [the Messiah’s] name? The Rabbis said: His name is “the leper scholar,” as it is written, “Surely he hath borne our griefs, and carried our sorrows: yet we did esteem him a leper, smitten of God, and afflicted.” (Sanhedrin 98b)
ScriptureCentral
scripturecentral.org › home › knowhy › why did isaiah prophesy of a suffering messiah? | scripturec
Why Did Isaiah Prophesy of a Suffering Messiah? | ScriptureC
May 31, 2024 - Many scholars question or reject ... written by anonymous writers from the time of the Babylonian exile in the sixth century BC or even later.17 The Book of Mormon, however, indicates that several of these chapters—including ...