So what exactly is so bad about Appeal to Emotion?
logic - What is, and isn't the appeal to emotion logical fallacy? - Philosophy Stack Exchange
What makes appeal to emotion fallacious if apparently every human behavior is fundamentally emotional?
"Appeal to Emotion" Fallacy
Why is an appeal to emotion fallacy problematic?
What are some other common fallacies related to the appeal to emotion fallacy?
So what exactly is so bad about Appeal to Emotion? People are emotional beings and much of their behavior is driven by emotional factors. Are they not? For example, lets say that you operate an orphanage and would like to solicit donations for the organization from the general public. Do you demonstrate to people that it is reasonable and proper to help orphans? Or, do you demonstrate to people that these kids have such a crappy, sad life thereby eliciting an emotional response in people to help these kids? It seems to me that the latter would be much more effective in persuading people. What's so wrong about that?
It does not have to be just orphans obviously. It could be any issue where there is the possibility to motivate people via empathy for others. What is so wrong about drawing out people's empathy? Isn't empathy a good thing?