๐ŸŒ
Torah Musings
torahmusings.com โ€บ home โ€บ is kabbalah heresy?
Is Kabbalah Heresy? - Torah Musings
August 12, 2013 - Missing from this discussion is the Sephardic school of Kabbalah, the actual talmidim of the Ari, the chain of transmission, and position of those with access to the authentic and accurate manuscripts. The Sephardic Kabbalaists, arguably the masters of the Lurainic corpus, held tzimtzum kipshuto.

type of Jewish mysticism

Kabbalah - Wikipedia
kabbalistic prayer book
Kabbalah or Qabalah (/kษ™หˆbษ‘หlษ™, หˆkรฆbษ™lษ™/ kษ™-BAH-lษ™, KAB-ษ™-lษ™; Hebrew: ืงึทื‘ึธึผืœึธื”โ€Ž, romanized: Qabbฤlฤ, pronounced [kabaหˆla] โ“˜; lit. 'act of receiving, acceptation') is an esoteric method, discipline and school of thought in Jewish mysticism. โ€ฆ Wikipedia
๐ŸŒ
Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org โ€บ wiki โ€บ Kabbalah
Kabbalah - Wikipedia
3 weeks ago - Around the 1230s, Rabbi Meir ben ... approach heresy. He particularly singled out the Sefer Bahir, rejecting the attribution of its authorship to the tanna R. Neแธฅunya ben ha-Kanah and describing some of its content as truly heretical. Leon of Modena, a 17th-century Venetian critic of Kabbalah, wrote that ...
๐ŸŒ
JSTOR
jstor.org โ€บ stable โ€บ 1455351
Halakhah, Kabbalah, and Heresy: A Controversy in Early Eighteenth-Century Amsterdam on JSTOR
Matt Goldish, Halakhah, Kabbalah, and Heresy: A Controversy in Early Eighteenth-Century Amsterdam, The Jewish Quarterly Review, Vol. 84, No. 2/3 (Oct., 1993 - Jan., 1994), pp. 153-176
๐ŸŒ
cakeordeathsite
cakeordeathsite.wordpress.com โ€บ 2018 โ€บ 07 โ€บ 04 โ€บ a-heresy-for-the-21st-century-the-kabbalah
A Heresy for the 21st Century: The Kabbalah | cakeordeathsite
July 4, 2018 - Gnosticism with its Dualism, distant God in the pleroma, not to mention the Demiurge who creates matter and the habit of turning scripture on its head, seems to be entirely inimical to Judaism with its monotheism and a God who is omnipotent, omnipresent and omnibenevolent. In many respects it is; yet within the mystical system of the Kabbalah there can be seen an attempt to combine strands of Neo-Platonism and Gnosticism with Judaism, albeit with a heavy qualified Dualism.
๐ŸŒ
Cambridge Core
cambridge.org โ€บ core โ€บ journals โ€บ harvard-theological-review โ€บ article โ€บ abs โ€บ philosophy-heresy-and-kabbalahs-countertheology โ€บ 7995C77BF0A4C918D66EFD8F1BAE5756
Philosophy, Heresy, and Kabbalah's Counter-Theology | Harvard Theological Review | Cambridge Core
April 6, 2016 - For the danger inherent in the esoteric lore kept secret by the fear of heresy see the famous words of R. Shlomo ben Meshulam da Piera: โ€œThey (R. Ezra and R. Azriel) know the Shiur, but they keep private the teaching out of fear of causing heresyโ€ (Silver, Maimonidean Criticism, 194). ... 85 โ€œKabbalah .
๐ŸŒ
Quora
quora.com โ€บ How-does-the-Orthodox-Christianism-see-Kabbalah-Is-it-considered-heresy
How does the Orthodox Christianism see Kabbalah? Is it considered heresy? - Quora
Answer (1 of 4): Christian Orthodoxy has a mysticism called Hesychasm which is pretty similar to the kabbalah: Just like the Ten Sephiroth from the Kabbalistic Tree of Life, Hesychasm has the Ten Order of Angels. Both Hesychasm and Kabbalah teach that there is a difference between Godโ€™s essence ...
Top answer
1 of 12
24

In Shu"t Mei'ein Omer pg 274 (not sure what volume, but it isn't volume 6, 7 or 8), a close student of Rav Ovadiah Yosef reports that a man once asked him if he needs to destroy a building he bought because it used to contain a synagogue of Dor De'im, a sect of Temani Jews who stick to strict Maimonidian philosophy and practice, and reject most if not all of Kabbalah. Rav Ovadiah Yosef responded that ืื™ ืืคืฉืจ ืœื“ื•ื ื ื›ื›ื•ืคืจื™ื it is not possible to judge them as heretics.

2 of 12
16

My Rebbe Rav Avigdor Nevenzahl Shlit"a told me that his Rebbe ybcl'c Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach zt"l when serving as mesader kiddushin at a wedding, upon hearing that one of the witnesses under the chuppa did not believe in Kabbalah or that Rebbe Shimon Bar Yochai authored the Zohar, had him replaced as a witness.

The explanation I was given was that although the beliefs in themselves are not heretical per se', nevertheless such beliefs are a red flag as to general kashrus of the person, and such a person is not fit to be relied upon for the effectiveness of the marriage. For a person to be willing to deny and argue with chachamim of great stature which professed belief in something for hundreds of years, is able to deny and argue other things in the Torah as well.

So based off this maaseh Rav the belief itself is not heresy, but it's not a good path to follow.

A version of this story is recorded by R. Hanoch Teller in And from Jerusalem his Word p. 231:

Another version of this story is recorded in this blog comment:

Interesting story with R' Shlomo Zalman Auerbach: One of his talmidim was a Yeminite bochur. Upon the bochur's engagement R' Sholomo Zalman was asked to be mesader kiddushin. Looking into the Eidim, R' Shlomo Zalman found out that one of them was a Baladi Rav of the bochur's family's shul, and someone who did not accept the Zohar etc. Worried that the rav might be posul for eidus, R' Shlomo Zalman called him up and asked him to be m'sedar kiddushin instead - telling the Rav that as longtime figure in the bochur's family life, it was more fitting that he have the kibud . . .

๐ŸŒ
Kesher Journal
kesherjournal.com โ€บ article โ€บ sabbateanism-and-nathan-of-gaza-giving-rise-to-messianic-heresy-through-the-combination-of-kabbalah-and-prophecy
Sabbateanism and Nathan of Gaza: Giving Rise to Messianic Heresy through the Combination of Kabbalah and Prophecy โ€“ Kesher Journal
By the late 17th century Lurianic Kabbalah and its teachings spread throughout the Jewish world.5 This is the background that surrounds the emergence of Sabbatai Tzvi and his kabbalist-prophet supporter, Nathan of Gaza.
Find elsewhere
Top answer
1 of 1
4

Welcome to MiYodeya. Here is the standard view of Kabbalah as understood by most Orthodox Jews.

Judaism is a divine religion: it was taught to us by an All-Knowing G-d far beyond our comprehension. When G-d created the world and wrote the Torah, he obviously did so in ways we cannot begin to fathom. However, we can understand a little bit beyond the plain appearance of reality and the plain understanding of Torah.

G-d revealed as much as a human could possibly understand to Moses, and he passed on that understanding to a select few disciples. They in turn passed on these teachings to a few select disciples. These teachings are commonly referred to by two names:

Kabbalah/Tradition: Because these matters can only be understood by transmission.

Torahs HaNistar/ The Torah of the Concealed: Because these matters relate to metaphysical concepts that are not tangible, and deeper meanings of verses beyond the surface meaning.

These teachings are not separate from Judaism, rather they are a deeper level of understanding. This leads to two corollaries:

  1. The Kabbalah does not contradict Judaism in any fundamental ways.
  2. Only one who has mastered the "revealed" part of Judaism is qualified to study it.

Because Kabbalah deals with matters that are by definition intangible, it must borrow terms such as "world", "light", "flow", etc. to simulate concepts that are beyond our perception. In truth it is highly abstract, and many people struggle with the books written by non-Kabbalists to explain these matters a little bit. This has also meant that people without the correct background misunderstand Kabbalah and thus see it as heretical (I saw the answer on the Christianity SE that is a classic of that "genre.")

Unfortunately, the vacuum of understanding has created attempts by many to "explain" Kabbalah without the proper background. Some people are well meaning, but some are outright charlatans trying to get rich off people's naivete.

The false Messiah Shabsai Tzvi misused Kabbalistic concepts to justify his fake claims and flagrantly transgress the Torah. That created a strong backlash to teaching Kabbalah to the masses that persists to this day.

Anyone who opens a "Kabbalah Center" or claims to teach Kabbalah to the masses is outside mainstream Judaism and not to be trusted. Especially anyone who attempts to use Kabbalah to raise money.

Anyone who treats Kabbalah as a separate religion from Judaism is not legitimate. Anyone who says that Kabbalah denies the existence of Satan or sin is flat-out wrong as wrong can be. (Although the Jewish -and therefore Kabbalistic- view of Satan is very different from the Christian/pagan dualist view.)

One last detail: Originally, Kabbalah was transmitted by word of mouth, as was the rest of the Oral Torah. Some parts of the Written Torah also contain Kabbalistic concepts, such as the visions opening the book of Ezekiel. As the Oral Torah began to be written down, so was the Kabbalah.

๐ŸŒ
Quora
quora.com โ€บ What-is-the-point-of-view-of-Orthodox-Judaism-to-the-esoteric-or-mysticism-teachings-such-as-Kabbalah-Do-they-accept-it-or-consider-it-as-heresy
What is the point of view of Orthodox Judaism to the esoteric or mysticism teachings such as Kabbalah? Do they accept it or consider it as heresy? - Quora
Answer (1 of 9): Kabbalah is a term describing a tradition of esoteric teachings that are deeply associated with Jewish ideas and values. Much controversy has been made about the origins of this material but its general distribution only occurred in the 12th and 13th Centuries of the Common Era. ...
๐ŸŒ
Chabad.org
chabad.org โ€บ learning & values โ€บ kabbalah, chassidism and jewish mysticism โ€บ chassidic thought โ€บ chabadthink โ€บ beyond heresy
Beyond Heresy - The Gโ€‘d in Which I Do Not Believe - Chabad.org
June 12, 2008 - If not for their scorn, how shallow our god would be! As one chassidic master told his disciple in reference to a certain heretic, "His heresy is closer to the truth than your faith."
๐ŸŒ
Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org โ€บ wiki โ€บ Heresy_in_Judaism
Heresy in Judaism - Wikipedia
September 7, 2025 - David Zvi Hoffmann: His work Mar Samuel judged to contain heresies by Samson Raphael Hirsch ยท Mordecai Kaplan: Excommunicated by Union of Orthodox Rabbis following the publication of his Sabbath Prayer Book ยท Louis Jacobs: Prevented from becoming British Chief Rabbi and removed from his pulpit due to his published views ยท Anthropomorphism in Kabbalah ยท
๐ŸŒ
CBGC
cbcg.org โ€บ home โ€บ booklets โ€บ judaismโ€” revelation of moses or religion of men?
Appendix Five - Kabbalahโ€”Judaism's Dark Side
August 10, 2016 - Kabbalism โ€œfed on pseudo-prophecy, superstition, myth, numerology and assorted odds and ends of heresyโ€ (Phillips, p. 71). Jews who did not โ€œfit in with Rabbinic Judaismโ€ sought refuge in Kabbalah, believing that โ€œits mysticism and ...
๐ŸŒ
ResearchGate
researchgate.net โ€บ publication โ€บ 300373283_Philosophy_Heresy_and_Kabbalah's_Counter-Theology
Philosophy, Heresy, and Kabbalah's Counter-Theology
April 1, 2016 - The framework of this article rests on the assumption that theosophical kabbalah shares with different philosophical traditions some important theological structures but also that it maintains important conceptual differences. In order to evaluate the theological tensions involved I will analyze different cases of theological heresies, both philosophical and theosophical.
๐ŸŒ
OUP Academic
fordham.universitypressscholarship.com โ€บ view โ€บ 10.5422 โ€บ fso โ€บ 9780823224180.001.0001 โ€บ upso-9780823224180-chapter-2
Differentiating (In)Difference: Heresy, Gender, and Kabbalah Study ...
December 1, 2004 - This chapter discusses the gender construction in kabbalistic lore. It explores the question of gender and the study of kabbalah that is cast into a broader conceptual framework.
๐ŸŒ
Oxford Bibliographies
oxfordbibliographies.com โ€บ display โ€บ document โ€บ obo-9780199840731 โ€บ obo-9780199840731-0177.xml
Modern Kabbalah - Jewish Studies - Oxford Bibliographies
According to Major Trends in Jewish Mysticism, Kabbalah found itself in a difficult position in the aftermath of the Sabbatian movement, a putative messianic โ€œheresyโ€ whose chief ideologues based their beliefs upon doctrines ...
๐ŸŒ
Bopsecrets
bopsecrets.org โ€บ rexroth โ€บ essays โ€บ kabbalah.htm
The Holy Kabbalah
Kabbalism and Hasidism seem, to a Christian taught in his own religion to view Gnostic and theosophic tendencies as the source of all heresy, to be a kind of Jewish heterodoxy. They are not. Jewish orthodoxy is not defined by the correctness of the answers it gives to metaphysical and cosmological ...
๐ŸŒ
YouTube
youtube.com โ€บ watch
Is Saying God Needs Us Heretical? Kabbalah Secrets ...
Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube.
๐ŸŒ
The Jerusalem Post
jpost.com โ€บ judaism โ€บ on-kabbalah-and-modern-orthodoxy-648128
On Kabbalah and Modern Orthodoxy | The Jerusalem Post
Perhaps Kabbalah can serve as both a model and inspiration for Modern Orthodoxy to continue to think โ€˜outside of the boxโ€™ and still remain grounded to its traditional past and to Halacha.