🌐
Google Scholar
scholar.google.com › citations
S.A. Rashkovskiy
S.A. Rashkovskiy · Institute for Problems in Mechanics · Verified email at hotbox.ru · Foundations of quantum mechanicsPropulsion PhysicsCombustion · ArticlesCited byPublic accessCo-authors · PrivacyTermsHelp ·
🌐
ResearchGate
researchgate.net › home › russian academy of sciences › institute of problems in mechanics › sergey rashkovskiy
Sergey RASHKOVSKIY | PhD, SciDr | Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow | RAS | Institute of Problems in Mechanics | Research profile
Sergey Rashkovskiy · We propose a phenomenological theory of spin behavior in a magnetic field, which explains from the point of view of classical physics the two-valued result of the Stern-Gerlach experiment.
🌐
Ipmnet
ipmnet.ru › ~rash › en
Sergey A. Rashkovskiy
Rashkovskiy S.A. Theory of Brownian motion in the Hamilton-Jacobi form. Physics of Fluids 37(3), 037199 (2025).
🌐
arXiv
arxiv.org › pdf › 1807.09152 pdf
Thermostatistics of classical fields Sergey A. Rashkovskiy
[3] Rashkovskiy S.A. Classical-field model of the hydrogen atom, Indian Journal of Physics, 91(6), 607-621 (2017). DOI: 10.1007/s12648-017-0972-8. [4] Prudnikov A.P., Brychkov Yu.A., Marichev O.I. Integrals and series. Moscow, Nauka, 1981, 593 (in Russian). [5] Gentile j.
🌐
Preprints.org
preprints.org › manuscript › 202210.0478
Phenomenological Theory of the Stern-Gerlach Experiment[v1] | Preprints.org
October 31, 2022 - Sergey Rashkovskiy * Show more · Version 1 · Submitted: 27 October 2022 · Posted: 31 October 2022 · You are already at the latest version · We propose a phenomenological theory of spin behavior in a magnetic field, which explains from the point of view of classical physics the two-valued ...
🌐
Research Square
researchsquare.com › article › rs-2498640 › v1
Phenomenological theory of the Stern-Gerlach experiment | Research Square
February 6, 2023 - Sergey Rashkovskiy · This is a ... · You are reading this latest preprint version · We propose a phenomenological theory of spin behavior in a magnetic field, which explains from the point of view of classical physics ...
🌐
Semantic Scholar
semanticscholar.org › papers › microwave-to-optical frequency conversion based on the lamb shift
[PDF] Microwave-to-optical frequency conversion based on the Lamb shift | Semantic Scholar
@article{Rashkovskiy2018MicrowavetoopticalFC, title={Microwave-to-optical frequency conversion based on the Lamb shift}, author={Sergey A. Rashkovskiy}, journal={arXiv: Quantum Physics}, year={2018} } S. Rashkovskiy · Published 17 June 2018 · Physics · arXiv: Quantum Physics ·
🌐
ResearchGate
researchgate.net › lab › Sergey-Rashkovskiy-Lab
Sergey V. Chalov's lab | Russian Academy of Sciences (RAS)
arXiv: 2009.12323 [physics.class-ph] It is believed that thermodynamic laws are associated with random processes occurring in the system and, therefore, deterministic mechanical systems cannot be described within the framework of the thermodynamic approach.
Find elsewhere
🌐
Springer
link.springer.com › home › indian journal of physics › article
Classical-field model of the hydrogen atom - Indian Journal of Physics
February 25, 2017 - Rashkovskiy, S.A. Classical-field model of the hydrogen atom. Indian J Phys 91, 607–621 (2017).
Top answer
1 of 3
5

As pointed out by Dr jh in his comment, the planetary model of the atom is wrong. Classical electrodynamics predicts that if electrons really did orbit the nucleus like little planets, the orbital motion would cause the electron to radiate its orbital kinetic energy away as electromagnetic waves and then fall all the way down into the nucleus- just as you say. Since this does not happen in reality, the model is incorrect.

There is no way to save this model "classically" because there is no classical mechanism by which to halt the orbital collapse of the electron. Quantum dynamics does, by establishing a ground state orbital energy level with no energy levels below it into which the electron could transition. Thus far it falls, and no farther.

2 of 3
2

Lord Raleigh determined the size of carbon atoms 1890-1900 by measuring the spread of a single layer of oleic acid on water, allowing estimating the size of an atom. By 1911 Rutherford had determined that the nucleus was about 10,000 times smaller than the atom as a whole. He proposed the planetary model about this time.

Arguing that the electron would spiral in and come to rest against the nucleus clearly doesn't work because of the size discrepancy. If one were to postulate that electrons are much bigger than nuclei the cross-sections and deflections found in Rutherford's experiment would not make sense.

The standard textbook explanation for the instability is just that in electrodynamics a charged particle moving fast in a circular orbit will radiate away energy. One could try to save things by suggesting that Maxwell's equations do not apply on the atomic scale. I have not seen any example of this being seriously proposed, but it is certainly a possibility - but an ugly one, especially to 1910s classical physics (especially since it would cast doubts on interpretations of the observations, which were implicitly Maxwellian). Still, Weber had an earlier and not very well-known theory of charges forming "molecular" atoms that involved a slightly altered electrodynamics.

The Bohr model explained discrete emission lines but still did not explain why there was no inspiral; this probably helped people make the jump to a quantized view where only some photons could be emitted.

One can apparently construct theories where the electron is a classical field instead of a particle, (Rashkovskiy 2016) gives an example. This is decidedly non-mainstream today and actually requires using the Dirac equation that came from quantum theory, but I can imagine some alternate history where early 20th century physics tried to patch the planetary model by electron-field waves - except that it looks to me that it would also quickly lead to the jump to the quantized view.

In short, one can always propose solutions to the stability problem, but solutions also need to make sense with the rest of physics. That makes many classical stability solutions look very awkward.

🌐
Semantic Scholar
semanticscholar.org › papers › semiclassical simulation of the double-slit experiments with single photons
[PDF] Semiclassical simulation of the double-slit experiments with single photons | Semantic Scholar
S. Rashkovskiy ... The detection of very weak classical electromagnetic (light) waves by classical macroscopic device is discussed. It is shown that the results of such detection can be interpreted as a manifestation… Expand ... It has recently been shown by Jaynes and collaborators that semiclassical radiation theory contains a description of spontaneous emission of radiation and of radiative level shifts. The present paper… Expand ... Physical review.
🌐
Google Scholar
scholar.google.com › citations
Radoslav Rashkov
‪Professor of Physics, Sofia University and Vienna Tech‬ - ‪‪Cited by 1,711‬‬ - ‪String theory‬ - ‪Quantum field theory‬ - ‪Supergravity. mathematical physics‬
🌐
Royal Society Publishing
royalsocietypublishing.org › rsta › article-abstract › 377 › 2157 › 20190096 › 58100 › Generalized-Fock-space-and
Generalized Fock space and contextuality | Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A | The Royal Society
November 4, 2019 - International Center for Mathematical Modeling in Physics, Engineering, Economics, and Cognitive Science, Linnaeus University, ... Electronic supplementary material is available online at https://dx.doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.c.4606799. One contribution of 16 to a theme issue ‘Contextuality and probability in quantum mechanics and beyond’. ... Philos Trans A Math Phys Eng Sci (2019) 377 (2157): 20190096 . ... Sergey Rashkovskiy, Andrei Khrennikov; Generalized Fock space and contextuality.
🌐
Scientific.Net
scientific.net › author-papers › sergey-rashkovskiy
Sergey Rashkovskiy | Scientific.Net
HomeSergey Rashkovskiy · Paper ... Sergey Rashkovskiy · Abstract: The direct 3D method of numerical simulation of gasless combustion of mechanically activated solid powder mixtures is developed....
🌐
AIMS
aimsciences.org › article › doi › 10.3934 › jgm.2020024
Hamilton-Jacobi theory for Hamiltonian and non-Hamiltonian systems
Rashkovskiy Sergey · Ishlinsky Institute for Problems in Mechanics of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Vernadskogo Ave., 101/1, Moscow, 119526, Russia · Received: April 2018 · Revised: July 2020 · Early access: September 2020 · Published online: September 2020 ·
🌐
Stack Exchange
physics.stackexchange.com › questions › 746623 › can-stern-gerlach-spin-alignment-be-seen-as-a-result-of-em-radiation-of-precessi
quantum mechanics - Can Stern-Gerlach spin alignment be seen as a result of EM radiation of precessing magnetic dipole? - Physics Stack Exchange
Update: Connor Behan below has found very nice article "Phenomenological theory of the Stern-Gerlach experimen" by Sergey A. Rashkovskiy with detailed calculations - getting $\sim 10^{-10}$s times for such alignment of atoms in Stern-Gerlach: https://www.preprints.org/manuscript/202210.0478/v1